2011-2012 Medicare Health Plan ratings according to the National Committee of Quality Assurance (9/20/2011).

Change your font size: A A A

Ohio Medicare Health Plan Ratings


Print This Page
Ranking Plan Name Type Score NCQA
Accredited?
Consumer
Satisfaction
Prevention Treatment
1 Kaiser Fnd. Health Plan of Ohio HMO 86.7 Checkmark Four Star Rating Five Star Rating Five Star Rating
2 SummaCare HMO/POS 84.3 Checkmark Five Star Rating Four Star Rating Four Star Rating
3 UPMC Health Plan PPO 84.3 Checkmark Four Star Rating Four Star Rating Four Star Rating
4 PrimeTime Health Plan HMO 84 Checkmark Five Star Rating Four Star Rating Three Star Rating
5 Aetna Life Insurance Company (Ohio) PPO 84 Checkmark Three Star Rating Four Star Rating Four Star Rating
6 UPMC Health Plan HMO 83.7 Checkmark Four Star Rating Four Star Rating Four Star Rating
7 Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield in Ohio PPO 83 Checkmark Four Star Rating Four Star Rating Three Star Rating
8 Paramount Health Care HMO 82.7 Checkmark Four Star Rating Four Star Rating Three Star Rating
9 Health Plan of the Upper Ohio Valley (H3672) HMO 82.3 Checkmark Five Star Rating Three Star Rating Three Star Rating
10 Aetna Health (Pennsylvania) - Ohio HMO 82 Checkmark Three Star Rating Three Star Rating Four Star Rating
11 Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield in Ohio HMO 81.3 Checkmark Three Star Rating Three Star Rating Three Star Rating
12 Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield in Indiana (Regional) PPO 81.3 Checkmark Three Star Rating Three Star Rating Three Star Rating
13 Health Plan of the Upper Ohio Valley (H5151) HMO 81.1 Checkmark Four Star Rating Three Star Rating Three Star Rating
14 Humana Insurance Company (Kentucky) PPO 81.1 Checkmark Three Star Rating Three Star Rating Three Star Rating
15 UnitedHealthcare of Ohio HMO/POS 80.3 Checkmark Three Star Rating Three Star Rating Three Star Rating
16 Humana Insurance Company (Ohio) PPO 80 Checkmark Three Star Rating Two Star Rating Two Star Rating
17 HealthAmerica Advantra (H5522) PPO 69.5 Red X Three Star Rating Three Star Rating Five Star Rating
18 Mt. Carmel Health Plan HMO 67.7 Red X Five Star Rating Three Star Rating Three Star Rating

The following plans do not have sufficient data to be rated: HealthAmerica Advantra (H8980), Humana Health Plan of Ohio, UnitedHealthcare of Ohio

Summary

Ohio residents have a great selection of Medicare Health Plans to choose from. Ohio has an incredible 16 NCQA accredited plans with scores of over 80. The top 5 plans score 84 or higher. The featured Medicare health plans are given ratings based on consumer satisfaction, prevention and treatment.