2011-2012 Medicare Health Plan ratings according to the National Committee of Quality Assurance (9/20/2011).

Change your font size: A A A

Pennsylvania Medicare Health Plan Ratings


Print This Page
Ranking Plan Name Type Score NCQA
Accredited?
Consumer
Satisfaction
Prevention Treatment
1 Geisinger Health Plan HMO 88 Checkmark Five Star Rating Five Star Rating Five Star Rating
2 HealthAmerica Advantra HMO 85.9 Checkmark Four Star Rating Four Star Rating Five Star Rating
3 Keystone Health Plan Central HMO 85.2 Checkmark Four Star Rating Five Star Rating Four Star Rating
4 Aetna Health - Pennsylvania HMO 84.7 Checkmark Four Star Rating Four Star Rating Four Star Rating
5 QCC Insurance (Personal Choice) PPO 84.6 Checkmark Four Star Rating Four Star Rating Four Star Rating
6 UPMC Health Plan PPO 84.3 Checkmark Four Star Rating Four Star Rating Four Star Rating
7 Aetna Life Insurance Company (Pennsylvania) PPO 84 Checkmark Three Star Rating Four Star Rating Four Star Rating
8 Highmark Health Insurance HMO 83.9 Checkmark Four Star Rating Four Star Rating Three Star Rating
9 UPMC Health Plan HMO 83.7 Checkmark Four Star Rating Four Star Rating Four Star Rating
10 Keystone Health Plan East HMO 83.5 Checkmark Three Star Rating Four Star Rating Four Star Rating
11 Bravo Health Pennsylvania HMO 79.1 Checkmark Two Star Rating Three Star Rating Three Star Rating
12 Bravo Health Pennsylvania (Senior Partners) HMO 79.1 Checkmark Two Star Rating Three Star Rating Three Star Rating
13 Keystone Health Plan Central PPO 69.4 Red X Four Star Rating Four Star Rating Four Star Rating
14 Highmark Health Insurance PPO 68.7 Red X Four Star Rating Five Star Rating Three Star Rating
15 Geisinger Health Plan PPO 68.6 Red X Four Star Rating Four Star Rating Four Star Rating
16 Gateway Health Plan HMO 65.8 Red X Three Star Rating Three Star Rating Three Star Rating
17 UnitedHealthcare Insurance (Pennsylvania Evercare) PPO 65.3 Red X Two Star Rating Three Star Rating Three Star Rating

The following plans do not have sufficient data to be rated: HealthAmerica Advantra (H8980), Humana Insurance Company (Pennsylvania), UnitedHealthcare of Pennsylvania

Summary

Pennsylvania offers 12 high scoring, NCQA accredited Medicare Health Plans with great ratings. An HMO plan from Geisinger Health Plan tops the list with an overall score of 88 and perfect (5 out of 5 star) ratings for consumer satisfaction, treatment and prevention.