2011-2012 Medicare Health Plan ratings according to the National Committee of Quality Assurance (9/20/2011).

Change your font size: A A A

Tennessee Medicare Health Plan Ratings


Print This Page
Ranking Plan Name Type Score NCQA
Accredited?
Consumer
Satisfaction
Prevention Treatment
1 Aetna Life Insurance Company (Tennessee) PPO 84 Checkmark Three Star Rating Four Star Rating Four Star Rating
2 Cariten Health Plan HMO 82.2 Checkmark Four Star Rating Three Star Rating Three Star Rating
3 UnitedHealthcare Plan of the River Valley HMO 80.7 Checkmark Three Star Rating Three Star Rating Three Star Rating
4 Humana Insurance Company (Tennessee) PPO 79.5 Checkmark Three Star Rating Two Star Rating Three Star Rating
5 UnitedHealthcare of Tennessee HMO 77.4 Checkmark Two Star Rating Two Star Rating One Star Rating
6 Healthspring of Tennessee (H4454) HMO 67.6 Red X Four Star Rating Four Star Rating Three Star Rating
7 HealthSpring of Tennessee (H4407) HMO 64.7 Red X Three Star Rating Three Star Rating Two Star Rating
8 Windsor Health Plan HMO 60.9 Red X Two Star Rating One Star Rating One Star Rating

The following plans do not have sufficient data to be rated: Aetna Health (Pennsylvania) - Tennessee, BlueCross BlueShield of Tennessee, UnitedHealthcare Plan of the River Valley (H0251)

Summary

The top five Tennessee Medicare Health Plans are NCQA accredited. The #1 spot goes to Aetna Life Insurance Company of Tennessee's PPO plan with an overall score of 84. Cariten (82.2), UnitedHealthcare (80.7) & Humana (79.5) take the next three spots. Ratings are based on consumer satisfaction, prevention and treatment.